Understanding Psychological Incapacity and the Declaration of Nullity of Marriage

What Are the Grounds for Declaration of Nullity of Marriage

Clients often come to us asking about annulment. In many cases, what they actually need is a petition for declaration of nullity of marriage. This is the legal remedy used when a marriage is considered void from the beginning. Several grounds can lead to nullity. Examples include a marriage contracted without a valid marriage license, a bigamous or polygamous marriage, or a marriage between close relatives who are prohibited from marrying.

The most frequently used ground is psychological incapacity under Article 36 of the Family Code. This is the provision people usually refer to when they say they want an annulment because their spouse is psychologically incapacitated. Although the term annulment is commonly used, psychological incapacity is technically a ground for nullity.

What Is Psychological Incapacity

Psychological incapacity refers to a deep and enduring personality issue that prevents a spouse from carrying out the essential obligations of marriage. This is not simply about unwillingness or temporary marital problems. The law requires that the incapacity already existed at the time of the wedding, even if it only became evident later on.

A spouse must genuinely be unable to perform basic marital duties such as living together, providing mutual love and fidelity, offering emotional and financial support, and, if there are children, exercising parental authority. The focus is on capacity, not choice. A spouse who refuses to cooperate or refuses to change is not automatically psychologically incapacitated. The courts look for something far more serious and deeply rooted in the spouse’s personality structure.

What Are Examples of Psychological Incapacity 

Psychological incapacity is not a diagnosis of mental illness. It is about a personality structure that makes married life impossible in practice.

One example is a spouse who, long before the marriage, already showed a consistent pattern of avoiding responsibility. This may include difficulty keeping a job, dependence on parents or relatives for support, and an inability to make commitments. After marriage, the same behaviors continue and the spouse refuses to contribute to the household or abandons the family for long periods. The behavior is not just irresponsibility. It is part of a long-standing personality pattern that the spouse cannot overcome.

Another example is a spouse who is emotionally detached to an extreme degree. This may be someone who cannot show affection, empathy, or concern. They may react coldly to serious situations and do not provide emotional support. If this emotional detachment has been present as far back as their early adult life, and if it becomes a problem throughout the marriage, it may indicate psychological incapacity because it affects the basic foundation of companionship.

A third example involves chronic dishonesty and infidelity, but with an important clarification. Ordinary cases of cheating do not qualify as psychological incapacity. However, a spouse who has a lifelong pattern of deceit, manipulation, and repeated affairs, combined with an inability to feel remorse or take responsibility, may be considered psychologically incapacitated. Here, infidelity is not the ground. The underlying personality disorder is what makes the spouse incapable of fulfilling the obligations of marriage.

These examples all share one thing. The behavior is part of an enduring personality pattern that existed even before the marriage and that makes it impossible for the spouse to function as a husband or wife.

What Is the Process of Filing a Petition

Filing a petition for declaration of nullity begins by bringing the case to the Family Court in the city or town where you or your spouse lives. Once the case is filed, the court informs your spouse that the petition exists. A government lawyer, usually called the public prosecutor, also takes part in the case. The prosecutor’s role is to make sure the petition is genuine and that the parties are not simply agreeing to end the marriage without proper legal grounds.

Before the actual hearings start, the court schedules a meeting called a pre trial. This is simply a chance for the court and the lawyers to organize the case, identify what needs to be proven, and confirm who will testify.

The case then proceeds to the hearings. You will tell your story under oath, and any witnesses you bring will also be asked to share what they know. You will also present important documents. Your spouse may choose to participate and give their own side. The prosecutor may ask questions as well.

After all the testimony and evidence have been presented, the judge will decide whether psychological incapacity has been clearly shown. If the judge grants the petition, the court will then settle related matters such as child custody, support, visitation, division of property, and whether the wife can return to using her maiden name.

What Do I Need to Prepare Before Filing

The most important preparation is a clear and detailed narrative of your relationship. The court needs to understand the personality of the incapacitated spouse as revealed through the earliest stages of the relationship, the period before the marriage, the wedding itself, and the events that followed. This helps establish that the incapacity existed before the marriage.

You should also identify witnesses who knew your spouse before and after the wedding and who can confirm the behaviors that support your case. Their testimony can be very helpful because it gives the court an outside perspective.

Supporting documents are equally important. These may include messages that show certain patterns of behavior, proof of abandonment, records of financial irresponsibility, or any relevant documents that confirm your experience. Some clients choose to obtain a psychological evaluation. This is no longer mandatory, but it can help explain the spouse’s personality structure in a clearer way.

The goal is to present a consistent and factual story showing that the spouse’s inability to fulfill marital duties is rooted in personality traits that existed long before the marriage and that could not realistically be corrected.

In the end, psychological incapacity serves as a legal recognition that some marriages were unworkable from the start due to deep-seated issues that prevented one spouse from fulfilling essential marital obligations. Understanding how the law views this ground allows individuals to see when a marriage may be considered void and what steps are available to formally close that chapter.

Need legal help?
Contact us and set an appointment today. Our team is ready to guide you through every step with clarity, compassion, and legal precision.